4.22.2011



CNN Article | OnIslam's Article

The recurring message we’re getting is that there is something inherently wrong with femininity. It’s a specter that haunts women by placing women into oppressive roles in society. It’s a specter that haunts men as an image of what not to be in fear of being labeled as a homosexual. We are socialized with the idea that femininity is “something that is evil and that should be purged,” (WAO). From the internalization of this type of thinking comes “masculinity camps” in Malaysia to re-socialize effeminate boys into dropping their feminine traits. The obvious analysis using our authors’ ideas is the binary gender opposition and notions of sexuality that Anne Fausto-Sterling elaborates in Sexing the Body. The appropriate image of femininity and masculinity are so narrow and strict that young Malaysian boys are being singled out as threats to this image. However, there is another analysis that can be made drawing from our more current readings about militarization where our authors like Enloe and Myers frame militarization as a masculinization process. These Malaysian boot camps are essentially total institutions that attempt to indoctrinate a need of being masculine into these stigmatized boys, a pressure that Enloe’s Borislav Herak experienced in the Serbian militia. By using these authors, we can explore the ways these Malaysian boot camps reinforce the binary gender system, heteronormativity and the role of masculinity and femininity in the nation building process.

The rhetoric behind these camps is primarily based on our two-gender system and what we have socially constructed them to look like. Malaysian boys are singled out for “effeminate tendencies” that do not fall under the stereotypes attached to the male gender whether it be liking a certain color or toy or the act of crying. This state is so plagued by the idea of gender ambiguity that even boys “surrounded by female siblings” are snatched up and placed into masculinity boot camps. By taking action to punish and re-socialize these young males, the Malaysian state department that is funding these boot camps is showing how intolerant they are of anyone that doesn’t categorize perfectly into the gender binaries. Fausto-Sterling’s criticism of the oversimplification of sex and anything that associates with it applies here perfectly; instead of having our label describe and work for us, we are defined and restrained by the label itself (54). Just as intersex newborns have to cope with the psychological pain afterwards for the decision someone had made for them, these Malaysian boys have to cope from being targeted and discriminated against by their own government at an age where many are already insecure and still developing. These psychological damages are all done in the name of reinforcing stereotypes and the two check box system: M or F.

With gender stereotypes come questions about sexuality. Though the camp authorities deny criticisms of the camp missions being homophobic and sexist, we cannot isolate the camp’s activities from the political and social context it’s in. Not only is homosexuality illegal in Malaysia, but Islam is also the official state religion in Malaysia, which “considers homosexuality unnatural and destructive to the social fabric” according to another article. Despite the adamant voices of denial from camp authorities, these camps are profiling and targeting homosexuals in order to “fix” them as if something is utterly wrong and needs to be “fixed.”

Though I struggled with this topic initially because on the surface it seemed like a men’s issue, I realized that it had everything to do and say about women as well. Enloe pointed out in her chapter mainly focused on men in militias that “constructing ideals of masculine behavior in any culture cannot be accomplished without constructing ideals of femininity that are supportive and complementary,” (Enloe, 107). So when these masculinizing camps say that they will make sure their boys leave with messages of physical strength, power, confidence, character, and national pride in their heads, what are they saying about femininity, about women? If they’re trying to cure these boys of femininity, these camps are also sending the reverse message that female qualities are characterized by weakness, fragility, subservience, and ill character. These boys are plagued with the disease of femininity and these camps are attempting to cure it and save them from qualities of the other gender. To actually go about indoctrinating these “masculine” qualities, the camps adopt ideas from a highly masculinized institution – the military.

Although the article states “the minister denied that the camp was a military-style…the students only march in unison every morning,” we have to look at the activities he didn’t think were “military-like.” Daud, the minister and authority figure of these camps tells readers that the boys participate in intensive activities that are fun. These fun activities that Daud describes are jungle-trekking, paintballing, aerobic workouts, lengthy visits to the mosque and “hoisting the national flag and reciting the Rukun Negara.” Despite Daud’s insistence of the militarial aspect of his camp, these activities have strong connections to militarial ones. Though it might not be able to pierce a skull, paintballing is an aggressive activity that gets the boys holding and using guns. Like we had discussed in class, masculinity seems to be tied closely with violence and aggression, traits the military cultivates. Though jungle-trekking may not ring a bell in terms of strategic militarization for Westerners, it is not merely a camping trip but relates to how wars are fought in Southeast Asia. If we look at militarization as a masculinization process, we can understand why these camps utilize military activities and techniques in working with these boys. The total institution aspect of the military helps Daud and his supporters break down the existing identity of these boys and to re-socialize “good” qualities into them. The point isn’t to merely teach the boys how to be masculine, but what’s even more vital is to raise these boys to “think of [themselves] as needing to be masculine,” a transformation of thinking Borislav Herak went through (Enloe, 101). After analyzing how these camps operate and institutionalize masculinity into these “effeminate boys,” we have to look at whom it benefits.

After the familiar ring of masculinity from the physical activities, the remaining activities stand at an interesting place. Whereas the physical portion of camp activities focused more on making the boys look and act like men, the patriotic and religious activities focused on the mindset of these boys and encouraged a very specific set of values and way of thinking. The mosque visits, marching, hoisting of flags, and the unison national chants is precisely the process of indoctrination and repetition of ideology and not just any ideology but the ideology of the state and the majority. The hegemonic aspect of these activities brings up questions about nation building and who plays a part in the process. Traditionally and historically, men are active participants of nation-building and these camps can be seen as a way to target young boys who have traits that threaten this male dominance in the construction of nationalism. Enloe brings up the interesting relationship between male patriotism and female patriotism and these camps are actively defining and solidifying the chasm between the two. Enloe notes that in “cultural constructions of masculinity…men [are] celebrated as soldiers…and women as chiefly [as] maternal sacrifices for the nation,” (Enloe, 107). The boys in these camps are learning how to be soldiers, learning how to cure themselves of a disease that might lead them to be a passive participant in the nation-building process, to prevent them from being the sacrificed. The role of the female patriot, as Enloe suggests, is to reinforce a brother, a father, an uncle – that is the role of feminism in the construction of nationalism and these “effeminate boys” not only blur gender lines, but also patriotic and nationalistic roles. These sprouting new boot camps attempt to reverse this by strengthening the militarization of masculinity. These boys need to not only feel like it’s their social duty to “man-up,” but a national duty as well.

After making the connection between militarization and masculinization, we can bring the discussion back to home and understand why the women in Myers’ article had such a rough time in the military. The military has traditionally been a field to cultivate and exercise dominance and power, traits labeled as masculine. With this come problems of sexual harassment and violence as men attempt to exercise their power and dominance over their female peers in the military.

Now the ultimate question: so what? Abu-Lughod brought up a good point; we tend to care about issues because they’re trendy. Instead, she challenges us to think about human rights. The profiling and targeting of these young, innocent Malaysian boys because they’re not expressing gender “correctly” is all due to our tendency to look at differences instead of commonalities. I think we’re taking the easy way out here, the path of least resistance. Instead of changing the way we think to make room for others in society, we turn them into problems with our rhetoric and try to change them. These corrective masculinity camps are easy because we don’t have to change ourselves; we’re not the problem, or are we?



News Flash #3: "Why Do We Let Them Dress Like That?"

http://www.npr.org/2011/04/05/135146130/moms-to-kids-youre-not-going-out-wearing-that

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703899704576204580623018562.html#articleTabs%3Darticle

The Wall Street Journal published an article on March 19th titled “Why Do We Let Them Dress Like That?” The title’s “them” refers to this American generation of teen and pre-teen girls…of course. The author, Jennifer Moses, has since been inundated with questions and follow up interviews from WSJ and NPR; the article itself has received over 650 comments (an unprecedented response that the Wall Street Journal has called a “tempest”). So, amongst all of the hotly debated issues, politics, and disasters that are published every day in the Journal, why is it that this topic struck such a nerve with readers? Why does the appearance of our female youth perpetually attract so much criticism? The opinions in this article provide a small window into our society’s view of women as liabilities and our projected need to look out for their best interest. Furthermore, by closely watching the reaction to this article, and how the greater media discusses this topic, we begin to better understand the complex nature of the social pressures on young women today.

A large portion of Moses’ article is spent justifying her complaint that young girls are simply dressing too scantily; and there are endless reasons why she thinks this is a dangerous problem. But I think that the value of the article (or rather, what has elicited the mass response) is in her answer to the question that the title asks. Why do we let them do it? The issue, Moses argues, is not with this generation of girls, but with this generation of parents – specifically, mothers. She says:

We are the first moms in history to have grown up with widely available birth control, the first who didn't have to worry about getting knocked up. We were also the first not only to be free of old-fashioned fears about our reputations but actually pressured by our peers and the wider culture to find our true womanhood in the bedroom.

It is helpful to recognize this distinction; personal histories and experiences are a large part of parenting, and changes in technology and society have certainly created a different background for this generation of moms. However, I think Moses’ statement fails to fully support the argument that follows it. She proposes that there are two main reasons that mothers have difficulty confronting their daughters about sexuality: (1) a fear of hypocrisy and (2) a vicarious thrill which mothers receive from having sexually attractive daughters (particularly as many mothers feel that they lose their own sex-appeal with age). I cannot imagine that these concerns are new, or even specific to this time and culture. American culture could not have gone from its puritan heritage to present day without this repeated cycle of a girl’s teen-aged rebellions affecting her mothering style down the road.

We should also be critical of how Moses’ allocates the responsibility to fix this “problem.” The article reads without any real consideration of the male role in this issue. The idea that boys or fathers are involved in any part of this is barely even hinted towards. In fact, the only time fathers are mentioned at all is in their assumed financial support of this style and behavior (which is also the only hint toward how consumerism may play a role). The absence of any male voice in these conversations and the lack of discussion about the male influence on female appearance show our society’s tendency to make problems concerning women just that. They are issues concerning only women, instead of issues that concern society. For example, in the NPR interview, Moses says, “clothing absolutely does send a message and if the messages is come grab my butt, I don't think we should be encouraging our youth to project that.” This shows how Moses’ perspective makes it the responsibility of the female to change her behavior in anticipation of the male’s reaction instead of the other way around. If attracting sexual misconduct is the concern, why not write the article about boys and title it, “Why Do We Let Them Act Like That?” Instead, Moses ignores the male role (and by doing so endorses it), leaving women with the burden of finding a solution to our violent sexual culture.

Female fashion trends clearly involve gender, and in order to understand it and why it makes so many people uncomfortable, we must look closely into how both males and females work to create these social norms and sexual politics. It is the same logic (in reverse) that Enloe employs when she examines nationalism alongside ideas of masculinity and femininity. It is impossible to fully understand the gender relations involving military men if we only look at the men; one must look deeper and consider how there might be a female influence, especially if the goal is to change it.

Except, in this case, one does not have to look very far to find the male influence on female fashion trends, which makes it even more disturbing that it is left out of this conversation. Moses’ article and the debates it has sparked offer a microcosm of the conflicting pressures on girls; they must both be attractive and reserved, desired and respected. Moses even acknowledges how this struggle extends to their mothers because, as parents, they want their daughter to be appealing but without the stigmas and dangers that may come along with that quality. And one cannot deny that these stigmas, desires, and dangers are stemming from more than the girls themselves. A vast majority of the demand for these styles is made in an attempt to please the male counterparts.

These sexual dynamics are what exist below the surface of Moses’ argument; implied in the tone of the article is the common myth that there is a direct and absolute correlation between displayed sexuality (in clothing choices) and acted sexuality. It is this assumption that creates such concern over clothing. If it was not a common belief that what you wear dictates how you act, I don’t think this article would have ever been written. At least, it would not have drawn so much attention.

In addition to questioning how this article reflects our culture, we must also explore how it contributes to it. Moses certainly has good intentions in writing this article. She wants to see confidence in young women without having them resort to self-objectification. But the way in which she presents this argument contributes to a larger form of patriarchy by steering the “blame” in a counter-productive direction. Instead of criticizing our society for promoting this behavior, this article criticizes mothers and daughters for being products of it. Perhaps Moses should instead be asking “Why Do We Make Them Dress Like That.” Overall, this article contributes to our society’s negative sexuality and adds to the pressures on women to reach an impossible standard. In order to create a more positive sexual culture, we need to stop blaming girls for their sexuality and start cultivating a positive environment that may encourage them to feel attractive and confident without having to express it in this way.

News Flash: CNN's Portrayal of RapeLay Videogame Silences Discussions of Violence Towards Women

CNN Video Discussion about "RapeLay" Videogame


We rarely hear discussions of rape in today’s media, and when rape does appear in the media, the discussions do not address the key issue: that rape is a serious act of violence against women, and it must be ended. I am focusing on a CNN video from March 31, 2010. The video addresses a videogame that was once available on amazon.com, called “RapeLay”. The object of the videogame is for players to find, corner, and rape women. Players can chose different methods of assault, and they can even get women pregnant and then force them to have abortions (See Article). The CNN video refers to these animated figures as “women”, although they look more like young teenage girls. The videogame was quickly banned from Amazon.com, but apparently it is still available for free download on many websites, and the intense media coverage of this game is largely responsible for it’s availability on the web. While the game itself is disgusting and unacceptable, the way that CNN discussed the game is also extremely disheartening. The entire discussion of the RapeLay game was centered on the idea that parents need to be on the look out for it, to make sure their kids do not play this game. The coverage includes zero discussion of violence against women. This CNN video shows that the media’s portrayals and discussions of rape are extremely skewed and fail to discuss the systemic issues of violence against women in our society. CNN’s portrayal of this videogame sheds light on the fact that discussions of violence against women continue to be stifled in the public sphere, which is consistent with Cynthia Enloe’s argument in her chapter, “Whom Do You Take Seriously?”.

I believe that CNN’s discussion of RapeLay focused on the wrong issues, because the video clip is all about how parents should monitor their children, and it fails to address the issues of violence against women that are present in the videogame. When I began watching the video, I expected the newscasters to address the idea that this game is degrading to women and reflects the violence against women that is present in today’s society. However, the entire story was framed in a way that completely ignored the idea that rape is the central focus of the game. For example, the opening line for the CNN video includes the male newscaster stating “What you are about to see is very disturbing. But parents, we have got to warn you about this videogame, because your kids could get their hands on it! It depicts rape.” It disturbs me that this is framed in terms of parents making sure their children don’t find this game. Of course, I agree that the discussion of parents making an effort to make sure their children do not get a hold of this game should definitely be included in the video segment. However, I think it is despicable that the main focus of the video is not about how degrading the videogame is to women, or about how rape is a serious crime. Cynthia Enloe has an explanation for this phenomenon: the CNN video does not discuss the issue of raping women because our society does not accept the discussion of certain women’s issues in the public sphere.

Enloe explains that a historical way to silence women’s issues has been to keep them out of the public sphere, and making an intense differentiation between the public and private spheres helps with this silencing. I argue that CNN chose to discuss the implications that this videogame has on parents monitoring their children instead of discussing rape as an issue in society because our media culture is afraid to bring rape into the public sphere. For example, at one point in the video, I was excited because I thought the male broadcaster was about to make a point about the issue of rape in the videogame. Instead, to my dismay, he said “this awakens a lot of parents to any violent video games, even if it’s not to this degree. What does this do to our kids, when they are playing the war games, and it’s just graphic violence, over and over again?” I expected him to discuss how this game awakens parents to violence against women, but instead he equated the rape videogame to other videogames that include war and other violence. Again, I believe that CNN used this tactic to guide their discussion because rape is not something that can be discussed in our public sphere, and news on television is about as public as a sphere can get.

After the male broadcaster spoke for a while, a woman named Cheryl was brought into the discussion via webcam. Because she is a woman, I thought that she might bring up a discussion of violence against women. However, her avoidance of the subject was even worse than the male broadcaster’s. Cheryl is apparently the co-founder of the Center for Mental Health and Media, and given this background I definitely expected her to comment on the psychological effects that a videogame like this could have on young girls who could potentially be exposed to it. To my great surprise, in her dialogue with the male broadcaster, Cheryl seemed to give an excuse for the videogame, suggesting that it wouldn’t be that damaging to children who are exposed to it. The male broadcaster asked Cheryl what the effects of this game could have on children, and Cheryl responded that the characters are “very crudely drawn, there is no genitalia shown”. I was infuriated by this response. Cheryl is implicitly suggesting that the game will not tell boys that it is okay to sexually assault girls and that the game willnot terrify young girls, simply because no genitalia is shown. She even goes on to say that it is normal for younger kids (especially boys) to play violent videogames, and she states that violence in our society is decreasing, not increasing. I was completely astounded that Cheryl did not mention the message that this videogame can and will send to children about violence against females. She completely ignored the fact that the violence in the game only targets women, and she essentially equated it to other violent games that involve war.

Similar to the reason that the overall CNN video did not discuss rape, Cheryl did not discuss violence against women because, according to Enloe, women who speak out about violence have historically been disrespected in society. Therefore, it is likely that Cheryl did not delve into a discussion of rape or violence against women because she felt that discussing the topic in such a public sphere would cause her to no longer be a “respectful woman”. Enloe explains that “in many societies, in many eras it has been deemed improper for any “respectable” woman to speak at a public meeting” (Enloe 75), let alone speak about rape in a public setting. Enloe also mentions that, historically, women have not only been disrespected for speaking in public about sensitive issues, but they have also been labeled as “prudish” or as lesbians for speaking about certain topics pertaining to women’s rights (Enloe 78). The fear of having these labels imposed on herself prevented Cheryl from discussing violence against women in the video. Cheryl, like so many women, was silenced.

We know that speaking about women’s issues is largely kept out of the public sphere. This known fact raises a question: Why does this CNN video about the RapeLay videogame exist at all, then? Why did the videogame receive any media coverage, if it is about rape? Enloe provides us with the answer to this question. Although women’s issues are generally not discussed in public, Enloe states that “violence against women almost everywhere has been a topic kept out of the public arena or only sporadically and very selectively allowed into it in the form of a “scandal””(Enloe 73). While our media ignores most rape cases, the RapeLay videogame was brought into the public sphere because of its scandalous nature. Although violence against women is common in our society, videogames depicting this violence are rare, but they produce public interest. Because the videogame was a “scandal”, it was brought into the public arena and was given media coverage.

CNN’s video coverage of the RapeLay videogame serves as a prime example of Enloe’s idea that discussions of women’s issues are silenced in the public sphere. Instead of discussing the videogame in terms of how it is extremely degrading and frightening for women, the videogame is simply discussed in terms of how parents should monitor their children’s videogame use. Not only does the framework of this discussion completely ignore women’s issues, but the woman who participates in the discussion never mentions the effect that this game has on both girls and boys in terms of legitimizing violence against women. The media avoids discussions of violence against women because the topic has historically been silenced in the public sphere. Cheryl does not bring up the discussion, and nor does the male broadcaster, because women have historically been devalued for speaking about women’s issues publicly. According to Enloe, the only reason that this story even made it into the mainstream media is because it was scandalous, and people are attracted to scandalous stories. In the future, I sincerely hope that CNN handles stories like this one in a very different fashion. Clearly, the main issue with the RapeLay videogame was how it encourages violence towards women. CNN failed to discuss this issue, and instead framed the story in a way to avoid bringing a discussion of violence against women into the public sphere.



Works Cited

Enloe, Cynthia. The Curious Feminist. Univ. of California Press, 2004.

CNN Video: http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/bestoftv/2010/03/31/pn.rapelay.parent.outrage.cnn?iref=videosearch

CNN Article: http://articles.cnn.com/2010-03-30/world/japan.video.game.rape_1_game-teenage-girl-japanese-government?_s=PM:WORLD