2.02.2011

Response Post Feb. 3

Douglas’ “New Girliness” is set up by the media idolizing the happy medium between Janet Reno and Cher from Clueless. Again, she tries to show how these programs would put on a façade of feminism or showcase decisively feminist moments, but Douglas persists that more subliminal messages were reaching the girls watching at home. Legally Blonde makes the statement that when a girl applies herself and sees her own worth, she can achieve anything. Still, though, Elle Woods was motivated mostly by the desire for a man (and later, the desire to spite that man). The charm of watching Miss Congeniality is seeing a completely non-feminine woman attempt and fail at the most feminine activities. She too undergoes a major change to be brought out of her extreme into the happy medium of femininity.

I found this chapter to be the least compelling of Douglas’ arguments thus far. (Perhaps I’m just growing intolerant of the inordinate amount of detail she gives on each plotline for each show or movie she references.) She is completely right, and justified in most of her opinions; but these observations seem too obvious to warrant their own chapter. This narrative of “finding the happy medium” is a generic Hollywood script not at all specific to femininity. There are countless films where the happy ending is achieved because the main character who was too tough, or too quiet, or too crazy or too ___________ learns a lesson and comes closer to the social norm. Happy Gilmore could be seen as one example. Happy is extreme in his rage and hitting ability, which gives him strange powers to hit a golf ball absurdly far. But it is only when he can leave that rage behind and come down from his extreme that he is able to piece his whole golf game, romantic life, and family life together amicably. Similarly, Austin Powers must lose his hyper-masculinity (his mojo) to realize the power inside him and the power of love. He can only achieve his happy ending if he parts with his overly-masculine ways.

These are just a couple movie examples showing that the same process that Douglas points out applies to more than just praising an “appropriate” level of feminism. In fact, I’d argue that the media gives the same pressures to men. Being hyper-masculine, like Arnold Schwarzenegger (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FoIlgdNxwrI) or Sly Stallone (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fh1ghJDHpgU&feature=related) will get you made fun of on SNL just as often as the public figures like Richard Simmons (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XArCup0hrLI)or Andy Dick. Maybe I’m just in the devil’s advocate mood, but I think the same can be said about Douglas’ next chapter. The pigeonholes that women of color fall into are not that different from the expectations that society casts on men of color, especially in comedy and television. This doesn’t mean that Douglas’ points are invalid or unimportant, I think we just need to be aware that these are conventions of society that aren’t specific to females or their struggle for equality.

"The Dragon Lady" and Enlightened Sexism


In the chapter, “You Go, Girl,” Douglas elaborates on how enlightened sexism can even be seen in media portraying women of color. Not only is gender at play, but also race. Though Douglas mainly focuses on African American women in the media, she briefly mentioned Asian Americans and her brief mentioning had me thinking about Asian stereotypes in the media throughout the two chapters.

Growing up, I felt the pressure to play down my “Asian-ness”. My parents pushed me to do all things they deemed “American”. From taking swimming lessons, to sticking me in front of the television learning English, I grew up thinking that there was something wrong with me because I had Chinese and Vietnamese blood in me. I also began to idolize T.V. characters and looking back, there were not many Asian characters I could idolize. I rarely saw Asians on T.V. or movies for more than a few minutes or episodes. They were never the leads. If anything, they were only casted to be the geek, the socially awkward one, or the one that does all the martial art moves.

Now, I’m starting to see some Asian women on T.V. and films. This should be something to celebrate about, but I can’t help but notice that most of these characters are highly stereotyped. Just hearing the names being introduced in the beginning of shows or movies makes me want to switch the channel. Following Douglas’ example of Ally McBeal, the Asian character in the show was named Ling Woo. J.K. Rowling’s named her Asian character Cho Chang. Aside from the name, Asian women are very popular for portraying the “Dragon Lady” stereotype that Douglas briefly touched on. Sure, the stereotype represents strong, forceful women that are usually adept at martial arts and flashing harsh glares, but it is no different from the warrior women that Douglas talked about in previous chapters. Underneath the mask of dominance in this “Dragon Lady” stereotype is a hypersexualized image of geishas, heartless and loveless spies, Vietnamese prostitutes in Vietnam war movies – the list goes on. This suggests that Asian-Americans would have to learn some killer martial art moves quick to look cool and sexy and even then, they will never find love because they’re heartless creatures.

I don’t even consider these stereotypes. I consider these images fantasies. In reality, most of my Asian-American friends grew up in a strict, conservative household where dominance, strength, and leadership were not to be said in the same sentence as words that even have a hint of femininity to it. Family roles are intertwined with gender roles. While the American media is busy portraying Asian women as strong, i-won’t-take-your-crap kind of women, reality is still going and I still don’t see a group of strong Asian females on the streets protesting, writing books and creating talk shows about pressing issues of our time. What the media is selling to us is a fantasy image of what a strong, successful Asian woman should look like, equipped with martial art skills and a sharp tongue. Is this really what young Asian girls in America should be striving for?

Douglas brings to point that no race is protected from enlightened sexism. The White teens have their “Clueless” while African-American teens have their “Living Single” and Asian-Americans have this:

Main Post February 2

Susan Douglas’s chapter 4, “The New Girliness”, explores television series and movies of the 1990s that served to redefine “girliness”. Douglas begins with a brief discussion of the Spice Girls, and lists multiple song titles and lyrics that exemplify girl power. It is interesting to note that the “girly girl” revolution emerged at the same time when “warrior women” (which we discussed in the previous class) were also very popular.

Before going into her discussion of television series and films, Douglas mentions a very influential and popular 1992 book called Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus, which sought to explain the fundamental differences between men and women. Another book from 1995 called The Rules intended to instruct women on how to find Mr. Right. One of the most striking lines from this book that Douglas chooses to share is “Let him open the door. Be feminine. Don’t tell sarcastic jokes” (105). Maybe this is just specific to Colgate or just my group of girlfriends, but my friends and I are all extremely sarcastic! This line about sarcasm really hit me. Not only am I sarcastic, but so is my mother and my sister (runs in the family). My mom managed to get married…so I guess there’s hope for me (Sidenote: even that was sarcastic. I’m doomed.)

Douglas then delves into long discussion of Fox’s 1997 hit, Ally McBeal. She notes that the program gave women power but would also plunge female viewers “into a sea of female incompetence, insecurity, and stammering” (107). The show covered an array of complex matters, including sexual harassment, and gender discrimination…yet it won the 1998 Golden Globe for best comedy. Although the show touched on such important matters, the matters were trivialized by intertwined comedy.

Douglas also discussed the character Bridget Jones (from Bridget Jones Diary), and notes that women are supposed to laugh at how pathetic Jones is with her constant need for male approval to feel good about herself. However, women were also supposed to identify with Jones and silently admit “Yes, I feel the same way”. Other movies that Douglas discusses include What Women Want, Miss Congeniality, Legally Blonde, and Down with Love. I have personally watched the last three of these films, and I agree with everything Douglas has mentioned about them. Miss Congeniality features an extremely “masculine” woman who is turned into a beautiful pageant girl. In contrast, Legally Blonde features a typical dumb blonde who learns to take herself seriously and gets a Law degree. Both of these films suggest that women cannot be ultra-feminine or anti-feminine; they must find a happy medium.

In Chapter 5, titled “You Go, Girl”, Douglas discusses the “sassy black woman” that we see portrayed in the media. Douglas suggests that African American women who use “black speak…make feminism hip, cool, and funny” (128). Miranda Bailey from Grey’s Anatomy is a prime example, and she commands the attention of her interns and superiors through her infallible use of language. Douglas expresses her desire to be like Dr. Bailey, because she has no problem telling any male superior what is on her mind. African American Women on television, such as Dr. Bailey, serve to say the things many women wish they could say, but feel that it would be overstepping their boundary.

Additionally, Douglas explores the complexities of the BET television network and hip-hop music videos. In music videos, African American women often appear in extremely revealing clothing, while dancing to offensive music. Douglas mentions that Spellman College, an all-women and predominantly African American college, would only allow Nelly to visit their campus if he agreed to speak about the sexism present in his music videos (unfortunately, Nelly refused). Douglas closes this chapter with a discussion of television shows that have an entirely African American cast, but an extremely white audience (such as The Cosby Show). This chapter of Douglas’ book really exemplifies some notable characteristics of white and black female popular culture characters, and she raised very interesting points that I have never considered before.