2.17.2011

Response Post 2.17

In class on Tuesday we spent some time discussing how, when encountered with an intersex newborn, physicians will make a decision about their sex, perform surgery, and declare the baby and boy or a girl. The class discussion and Anne Fausto-Sterling’s chapter “Of Gender and Genitals” both suggest that the doctors are doing something wrong by “choosing” the sex of the baby. I know that there are complicated effects of essentially assigning a sex to a baby. The child will inevitably have a hard time growing up, because he may have been “created” into a baby boy, but perhaps the internal neural and hormone system is quite female. I am not denying the fact that it would be incredibly hard to have a sex forced on you if you were born intersex.

However…I argue that the psychological affects of being intersex into today’s modern American society would be far worse than having a certain sex forced upon you. Imagine if an intersex baby remained intersex, neither a male nor a female. What would people refer to this child as? A he or a she? As humans, we have a natural tendency to categorize. When babies are born, girls usually receive a pink hospital bracelet and/or cotton hat, while boys receive blue bracelets and hats. Categorization of sex (with only the male and female option) is so engrained into our society that newborn baby girls receive a pink bracelet minutes after being born. What color bracelet would an intersex baby receive? What color would the parents paint an intersex baby’s room? What would be baby’s birth certificate say, if the hospital could not check the male or female box?

I’m not saying that there should only be two sexes. I don’t think it’s right that someone who is born as intersex is automatically made into either a male or a female. However, until society can accept “intersex” as a third category of sex in addition to male and female, I think it would be impossible to grow up as an intersex child. Because our society is so concerned with sexual identity, the psychological effects of being intersex would be extremely debilitating and would prevent this child from leading a happy life.

I’m going to conclude with an example. Let’s say a baby is born, and this child happens to have 6 fingers on one hand. The sixth finger does not present any medical emergency and the child would be perfectly fine with that sixth finger. However, the parents and the doctor decide to amputate the sixth finger so the child can lead a more normal and easier life. In elementary school, children learn to count to 10 on their 10 fingers, when you get married there is a specific wedding finger, etc. A child with six fingers would face difficulties in society due to his or her abnormality. Therefore, it would be silly to leave the sixth finger there when it could easily be amputated.

I think that this example relates to intersexuality, although sex is definitely different than a simply sixth finger. Similarly though, a child who is intersex would face so many problems growing up in our society. I think at this moment in American society, it would be irresponsible of parents and doctors to allow a child to remain intersex, because it would be promising a very hard life to this newborn baby.

2.16.2011

Response Post Feb. 17

Gender and Genitals & Should There Be Only Two Sexes

While reading these chapters and thinking about our perceptions of “proper” medical practice at birth, I could not help but wonder if this dilemma can ever be solved with any amount of medical knowledge or legal specifications. In my opinion, it falls into the strange category of parenting and government that involves making decisions for people without a voice. I suppose you could say it isn’t too different from the cultural practice of circumcision. What began as a religious ritual turned into a medical practice because it was believed to promote health; but now it is relatively accepted that the decision to circumcise is purely for the benefits of fitting in. This idea about society making decisions for others (the unborn or newborn) often enters on the pro-life side of the abortion debate. The abundance of these arguments and dilemmas around how infants are cared for medically shows how dynamic and constructed our society truly is. It is also a testament to how quickly we begin to be acclimated to the society. Undoubtedly, I think an endless search for understanding and a sincere dedication to communication is key to having any semblance of order in these complicated areas of our society.

Safety and health should always come first. This is obvious. It is ignorant to assume that any given individual would want to undergo a rash gender assignment surgery without weighing options, emotions, risks, etc. But, rather than speak vaguely on my opinions which are likely to agree with most of my classmates’, it may be more interesting to try to argue the opposite:

One could argue it is equally as presumptuous to assume that a child would not want these decisions to be made early. Unfortunately, it seems almost inevitable in our current society that a child born with ambiguous genitalia, or even if they just show ambiguous gender traits, will encounter adversity. One could argue that making the decision for a sexually ambiguous newborn affords them (as unfortunate as it may be) a higher chance at social acceptance (which is undeniably important to human psychological health). One could argue that the gender assignment decision has the chance of being “right,” that it will align with the individual’s personal gender identification and allow them to lead a much less complicated life. One might even argue that drawing attention to the issue of gender assignment only further ostracizes those that are born under these circumstances, and that by condemning all gender assignment decisions people are also condemning those who feel they have lived happier lives because of it.

These are just a few counterpoints I could think of. Naturally, they have flaws and this issue is endlessly complicated; but this is my attempt to understand all sides of the issue.

2.15.2011

Leading Post: Of Gender and Genitals & Should There Be Only Two Sexes


Anne Fausto-Sterling – Of Gender and Genitals


This chapter is very informational with descriptions of the 4 different types of intersexuality: CAH, AID, XO, and XXY. Sterling also sheds light on how physicians respond when they are encountered with a sexually ambiguous infant. Sterling shows how infant genital surgeries are rash and impulsive decisions and are based off of baseless standards such as penis size. What is more outraging is how the decision can be made based on which surgery is easier for the surgeon. The manner in which physicians approach intersex infants supports our society’s strong disapproval for anything that strays away from the norm and even the health of these intersex patients are insignificant, thus, arbitrary medical decisions are acceptable.

Another problem is how uninformed physicians want the parents to be. The parents are not told the whole truth and are not given enough time to deliberate and make a decision. Surely, not enough time is given to the child to choose for him or herself. Sterling’s description of how physicians operate in this type of situation makes me wonder about malpractice and if society even cares if this is seen as malpractice…

Anne Fausto-Sterling – Should There Be Only Two Sexes?


Sterling proposes her 3-step plan towards positive change in this chapter.

1.) A change in medical management of intersexual infants and a cessation of unnecessary infant genital surgeries
2.) An assignment of a provisional sex
3.) Provide long-term counseling for the parents and the child.

I like Anne Fausto-Sterling’s 3 steps towards change, especially the first one regarding the cessation of infant genital surgery for cosmetic reason and social results. I think that it is outrageous for physicians, who ostensibly have our best interests in mind, to disregard the high failure rate of such surgeries, the happiness and well-being of the patient, as well as the function of specific body parts in order to please the two-gender system.

The medical argument about aesthetics over function makes me think about the second wave feminists and the fight for sexual revolution. This entire argument over the clitoris and the belief that male sexual pleasure is more important fits right into the agenda of second wave feminists. This is something that should be given more attention to because physicians are basically inducing lifelong physical and mental pain to their patients. Some patients say that they never truly recover from a clitorectomy, vaginoplasty, or phalloplasty. Patients suffer from dense scarring, hypersensitivity, and even the inability to achieve orgasm. If the medical field exists to heal people and maintain the health of people, the medical field’s response to intersexual infants does not reflect this philosophy. Someone needs to be called out because something has got to change.