2.15.2011

I like that Fausto-Sterling embraces in discussion with multiple facets of our society. I think it has been a trend in our reading, and in academia in general, to focus very specifically on a central thesis within one aspect of feminism, or media, or science. But Fausto-Sterling spreads her argument to apply to the multiple forms through which our society’s “norms” manifest themselves, which I think strengthens her points rather than making them unfocused or disorganized. Using our society’s need for strict gender and sex definitions is a good way to show how norms are constructed from the moment a person enters the world. I remember learning about a few counter examples in an Anthropology class I took abroad. For example, there are some pacific island cultures in which families will raise male children as women if they have not had any female children; it is a third gender called fafafini. This allows them to stay home and help around the house, but the males selected to be females are completely accepted members of society and are not seen as strange or non-normative. They are sexually active and revered for their ability to have both masculine and feminine attributes. There are a number of examples like this that support Fausto-Sterling’s argument that gender is a construct and can be approached differently if the society so chooses.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EronVtKYr0c&feature=player_embedded#at=28

2.14.2011

Main Post: Feb. 14

Chapter 1: Dueling Dualisms

In chapter 1 of Sexing the Body, Anne Fausto-Sterling opens with a discussion of Maria Patino’s experience in the 1988 Olympics. This Spanish athlete failed the “sex test” at the Olympics. Patino thought she was a female her entire life, but apparently she lacked overies and a uterus. Patino’s case was debated for almost three years, and eventually the IAAF reinstated her and she was able to complete in the olympics again. Patino serves as an example for one of Fausto-Sterling’s biggest questions in her chapter: why is it so important to define sex in our society?

Fausto-Sterling then launches into an interesting discussion the many spheres of her life. She interacts frequently with biologists, people on a listserve (loveweb), and feminists. Fausto-Sterling’s three different spheres give her writing more credibility, I think, because she shows that she has been exposed to many different perspectives. I admire the way that she is able to navigate through these three different worlds.

Next, Fausto-Sterling discusses the history of sex and gender, and the differences between the two. One of the most compelling ideas is that our society feels the need to strictly define sex and gender. If a child is born with multiple genitalia, the doctor (and parents) usually make a decision and remove something in order for the child to be a defined “sex”. Additionally, on the U.S census, we can only check “male” or “female”, which poses a huge problem for individuals who are born with ambiguous or multiple genitalia. She discusses gender and sex differences in Ancient Greece and throughout history. The “nature or nurture” debate is also present in this chapter. I think the most interesting point here is that sexual behavior can be driven by an “impulse” or by a social construction. Finally, the author discusses the importance of dualisms in our everyday analysis of society, and how dualisms reinforce social constructions (such as gender).

Chapter 2: The Sexe Which Prevaileth

In chapter 2 of Sexing the Body, Fausto-Sterling discusses “hermaphrodite history”. Following from my comment about the U.S census and its strict gender definitions, I think that this chapter is an important one. The author explains a history of how hermaphrodites have been treated in society, suggesting that they have been regarded as “rebellious, disruptive, or even fraudulent” (34). In Europe, strict distinctions between males and females were part of the legal and political systems throughout history. This was due to rights of inheritance, judicial punishment, the right to vote, etc. Therefore, hermaphrodites encountered a huge problem: their “inter-sex” made it hard to know their legal and political rights. The title of the chapter comes from Sir Edward Coke who was a jurist in England: “an Hermaphrodite may purchase according to that sexe which prevaileth” (36). Hermaphrodites chose a sex with the help of medical and legal experts, and once the choice was made there was no going back.

Luckily, as society has progressed, scientists have come to better understand the “modern intersexual”, and they can usually be identified immediately at birth. Additionally, the idea of intersexuality has contributed greatly to the argument about sex and gender. Doctors today tend to want to make a decision about a child’s sex if they are born intersex. This is because there is a general assumption in society that there should only be two sexes, that heterosexuality is the norm, and that gender roles define the man and woman (44). These conventions shape society’s view on intersexuality and gender.

Response: Anne Fausto-Sterling



After spending the past weeks talking about gender, Fausto-Sterling’s excerpt on sexual identity helped me further see the differences between sex and gender. In addition, this excerpt also problematized arguments about sex. I thought that sex was relatively easy to determine because physical characteristics are easier to determine than gender identity. However, Sterling shed light to the reality that sex, just like gender, is not dichotomous; there are many shades of gray in between. Sterling points out that sex is also constructed – by physicians and especially in the Age of Conversion.

What causes this problem is our obsession with oversimplification. This makes it harder to break away from thinking in terms of binaries and only binaries. We like order, and we like definite answers, but by categorizing everything, we end up forcing labels on things that cannot be defined by a simple label. This applied to things even outside of gender. If we go to the bookstore, we can see books erroneously labeled. We see self-help books that fall under the category of pseudoscience in the Psychology shelves. We see hybrid genres like Spielberg’s Maus causing problems for people who do the labeling because labeling Maus as a comic book dismisses the fact that it also incorporates a biography, a historical event, and even an auto-biography. Now, we face the consequences of oversimplifying sex. Even if we are able to get physicians to acknowledge the multiplicity of sexes, I think that’s only half the battle. The other half entails society to accept that reality.

What really stuck with me after finishing the reading was Sterling’s observation that our sexual organs seemed to dictate who gets rights in our society. When she puts it this way, it seems silly that if one has a penis, they get more pay, more political rights and gain more societal benefits. Also, I was really interested in the debate on nature versus nurture in determining sexuality. I don’t know where I stand on this debate because I don’t think I have enough background on both sides to take a stance. Regardless, I think that it’s very fascinating. However, I don’t think this should outweigh the debate over the variety of sexes that exist. Should we continue to live in a society that allows physicians to choose your sex if it’s questionable? Should a choice even be made?